The No. 1 Payday Loans Near Me 550 Mistake You are Making (and 4 Ways To fix It)

If a 401(k) loan is a good idea, it makes sense.

401(k) Loan Basics

The 4 most compelling reasons to borrow

Stock Market Myths

Debunking Myths With Facts

401(k) Credits to Purchase the Home of your choice

The Bottom Line

Retirement Plan 401(k)

4 Reasons to Borrow from Your 401(k)

The ideal time to take an 401(k) loan? When the market is falling

By Troy Segal

Updated 25 January 2022

Read by David Kindness

The factual information is verified by Skylar Clarine

Skylar Clarine

The financial press has come up with some negative terms to explain the dangers when borrowing funds from the 401(k) program. Some experts, including financial planners, may claim that taking a loan from the 401(k) plan is a crime of theft to derail your retirement.

But it is true that a 401(k) loan can be acceptable in certain circumstances. Let’s examine how such a loan can be utilized in a responsible manner and how it doesn’t spell trouble for your retirement savings.

The most important takeaways

When done for the right reasons, taking the short-term 401(k) loan and paying the loan back on time isn’t necessarily a bad thing.

Reasons to take out a loan from your 401(k) include the speed and convenience and flexibility in repayment as well as cost savings, and the potential for advantages in your pension savings in a declining market.

Common arguments against taking loans loan are negative effects on investment performance, tax inefficiency, and that leaving a job with unpaid loan can have unintended effects.

A depressed stock market could be one of the best times to apply for the 401(k) loan.

If you need a 401(k) Loan is the right choice,

If you need to find funds for a critical immediate liquidity issue then a loan taken from your 401(k) plan could be one of the first places you should look. We’ll define “short-term” as roughly a year or less. It is possible to define “serious liquidity need” as a significant one-time demand for funds or a lump-sum cash payment.

Kathryn B. Hauer, MBA, CFP(r), a financial planner at Wilson David Investment Advisors and the author of Financial Advice for Blue Collar America explained it in this manner: “Let’s face it, in the real world, sometimes people need money. The borrowing option through your 401(k) can be financially smarter then taking out a cripplingly high-interest title loan or pawn payday loan–or even a more affordable personal loan. It will cost you less in the longer term. “1

Why is the 401(k) an attractive source of short-term loans? It’s because it’s the most efficient, simple, and cost-effective way to obtain the money you require. A loan via your 401(k) is not tax-deductible, unless the loan limits and repayment rules are not followed, and it has no impact on your credit score.

If you repay the short-term loan according to the timeframe, it usually will have little effect on your retirement savings progress. In fact, in certain instances, it could have a positive impact. Let’s look a bit deeper to understand the reasons.

Image

Image of Sabrina Jiang (c) Investopedia 2020

401(k) Basics of Loans

Technically, 401(k) loans are not true loans since they don’t require a lender or an evaluation of your credit background. They can be defined as being able to access a part of your retirement plan’s money, usually as much as 50% or $50,000 of your total assets or less, on an tax-free basis.2 You then must pay back the funds you access to under rules that are designed to bring the condition of your 401(k) program to approximately its initial state, like if the transaction has not occurred.

Another confounding aspect of these transactions is interest. The interest that is charged on the outstanding loan balance is paid back by the participant to the participant’s personal 401(k) account, which means that technically, it is a transfer from your pocket to another, and not an expense for borrowing or loss. This means that the cost of the 401(k) loan on your retirement savings progress can be low, neutral, or even positive. But in most cases, it’ll be less than the cost of paying the real cost of interest on a consumer or bank loan.

How to Be a 401(k) Millionaire

Top 4 Reasons to Borrow from Your 401(k)

The most important four reasons to go at your 401(k) for serious short-term cash needs are:

1. Speed and Convenience

In the majority of 401(k) plan, getting an loan is easy and fast and does not require lengthy application as well as credit screening. Normally, it does not cause an inquiry to your credit score or impact the credit rating.

Many 401(k)s permit loan request to be submitted with just a few clicks on the website and funds could be in your hand in a few days, with total privacy. One new feature that is being used by some plan is the use of a debit card, through which multiple loans are made instantaneously in smaller amounts.3

2. Repayment Flexibility

While regulations require an amortizing five-year repayment plan, for most 401(k) loans, you can repay the plan loan faster with no prepayment penalty.2 Most plans allow loan payment to be done easily through payroll deductions using tax-free dollars, but not pretax dollars that fund your plan. Your statements from your plan will show the amount of credit towards your loan account and your remaining principal balance, just as a normal bank loan statement.

3. Cost Advantage

There is no cost (other than perhaps a modest loan administration or origination fee) to access your personal 401(k) money for immediate liquidity requirements. Here’s how it usually works:

You choose your investments account(s) from where you wish to borrow money, and these investments are liquidated during the time period of your loan. Therefore, you lose any gains that would be earned from those investments for a short period. In the event that the market is in decline then you will be selling these investments for less than other times. It’s a good thing because you will not suffer any future losses to your investment cash.

The benefit of the 401(k) loan is the equivalent of the interest rate of a comparable consumer loan minus any lost profits from investments on the principal amount you borrowed. Here is a simple formula:

Cost Advantage = Cost of Consumer Loan Interest. EarningsCost Advantage = Cost of Consumer Loan Interest and Lost Investment Earnings

Let’s suppose you apply for a personal loan or cash advance with credit card at an interest rate of 8. Your 401(k) investment portfolio could be earning 5 percent return. Your benefit from using the 401(k) plan is 3percent (8 5 x 8 equals 3).

When you know that the benefit from cost is positive and a plan loan could be appealing. Keep in mind that this calculation does not take into account any tax impact which could boost the benefits of a plan loan since consumer loan interest is repaid with tax-free funds.

4. Retirement Savings Can Benefit

As you make loan payments to your 401(k) account, they usually are allocated back into your portfolio’s investments. The account will be repaid a bit more than you borrowed from it, and this is referred to as “interest.” The loan has no (that is to say that it has no) effect on retirement plan if loss in investment earnings are equal to the “interest” that you pay in–i.e. the earnings potential are offset dollar-for-dollar with interest payments.

If the interest paid exceeds any lost investment earnings, taking a 401(k) loan can actually improve your retirement savings. Remember, however, that this could reduce your personal (non-retirement) savings.

Stock Market Myths

The above discussion leads us to address another (erroneous) argument regarding 401(k) loans: By withdrawing funds, you’ll drastically slow the progress of your portfolio as well as the growth of your retirement savings. This isn’t necessarily the case. In the first place, as noted above, you do have to repay the funds and you begin to do so fairly soon. With the long-term outlook of the majority 401(k)s this is a fairly small (and financial insignificant) interval.4

19%

The percentage of 401(k) participants with outstanding loans as of 2016 (latest information) as per an analysis by the Employee Benefit Research Institute.5

The other problem with the bad-impact-on-investments reasoning: It tends to assume the same rate of return over the years and–as recent events have made stunningly clear–the stock market doesn’t work like that. A portfolio that’s geared toward growth that’s weighed towards equity will experience fluctuations and ups, particularly in the short term.

In the event that you have a 401(k) is invested in stocks, the real effect on shorter-term loans in your retirement goals will depend on the current market environment. The impact is likely to be mildly negative in up markets that are strong however it could be neutral or positive in sideways or down markets.

The good and bad newsis that the ideal time to take the loan would be when you believe the stock market is vulnerable or weakening, such as during recessions. In the course of time, many find they require money or to remain liquid in these periods.

Debunking Myths With Facts

There are two other popular arguments that are made against 401(k) loans: The loans aren’t tax-efficient, and can cause huge problems when the participants aren’t able to pay them back prior to leaving their jobs or retirement. Let’s dispel these myths by presenting facts:

Tax Inefficiency

The claim the claim is 401(k) loans are tax-inefficient because they must be repaid using after-tax dollars, which exposes loan repayment to taxation double. Only the part of the repayment that is financed by interest is subject to this treatment. Media often ignore the fact that the price of double taxation of loan interest is often fairly tiny, when compared to the costs of other ways to tap short-term liquidity.

Here’s an example that is too often very real: Suppose Jane makes steady retirement savings by deferring 7percent of her earnings to her 401(k). However, she will soon need to tap $10,000 to pay for a cost of tuition for her college. She expects to pay back this amount by taking her salary for about a year. She is in the 20% tax bracket for both the state and federal. Three ways she could access the cash:

Borrow the money from her 401(k) at an “interest percentage” of 4.4%. Her cost of double-taxation on the interest is $80 ($10,000 loan x 4% interest plus 20 percent taxes).

The bank will let you borrow at a rate of real interest of 8percent. The cost of interest is $800.

Stop making 401(k) account deferrals for a year and use the funds to pay her college tuition. In this scenario, she will lose real retirement savings progress, pay more income tax in the current year, and potentially lose any employer-matching contributions. The cost could easily be $1,000 or more.

The double-taxation associated with 401(k) loan interest becomes a meaningful cost only when large amounts are borrowed and then repayed over multiple years. However, even then, it typically costs less than alternative means of getting similar cash via bank or consumer loans or a pause in deferrals to plan.

Resigning from Work with an unpaid Loan

Imagine you take out a loan and then lose your job. You’ll have to pay back the loan in total. If you don’t, the full not paid loan amount will be classified as a tax-deductible distribution and you could be subject to an additional 10% federal tax penalty on the unpaid balance if you are under age at 59 1/2 .6 Although this is the most accurate way to describe tax law, it may not always reflect reality.

When they retire or leave working, many people decide to use a portion or all of the 401(k) funds as a tax-deductible distribution particularly when they are cash-strapped. Having an unpaid loan balance has the same tax consequences as making this choice. The majority of plans do not require plan distributions upon retirement or separation from service.

People who want to avoid tax penalties can use other sources of income to repay the 401(k) loans before taking a distribution. If they do this the entire balance of the plan could be tax-advantaged rollover or transfer. If an outstanding loan amount is included as part of the plan participant’s taxable income and the loan is subsequently repaid, the penalty of 10% is not applicable. apply.7

The more serious problem is to take 401(k) loans while working without having the intent or ability to repay them on schedule. In this situation, the unpaid loan amount is treated similar as a hardship withdrawal with tax consequences that can be negative, and perhaps also an unfavorable impact on plan participation rights.

401(k) Loans to Purchase a Home

Regulations require 401(k) plans loans to be paid back using an interest-based basis (that is, with a fixed repayment schedule with regular installments) in no more than five years, unless they are loan is used to buy an primary residence. Payback times that are longer are permitted for these specific loans. The IRS does not provide a timeframe for the loan, though, so it’s something you’ll have to negotiate with the plan’s administrator. And ask whether you get an additional year due to the Cares bill.2

Remember that CARES increased the amount that the participants are able to take out of their plans up to $100,000. Prior to this, the maximum amount that participants may borrow from their plan is 50% of the vested account balance or $50,000, whichever is lower. If your vested account balance is less than $10,000, then you are still able to borrow up to $10,000.2

Borrowing from a 401(k) to finance completely an investment in a house isn’t as attractive as an mortgage loan. Plan loans don’t provide tax-free interest payments like the majority of mortgages. While taking out and paying back your loan within 5 years is acceptable under the normal rules that is 401(k) things, the impact on your retirement goals for a loan that has to be paid back over a number of years can be significant.

However an 401(k) loan might work in the event that you require urgent cash to pay for the down payment or closing costs associated with buying a home. It won’t impact your ability to qualify for a mortgage, either. Since the 401(k) loan isn’t technically a debt–you’re withdrawing your own money, after all–it has no effect on your debt-to-income ratio or on the credit rating, two major aspects that impact lenders.

If you need to borrow a sizable sum to purchase a house and want to make use of 401(k) funds then you could look into a hardship withdrawal in lieu of or in addition to the loan. However, you’ll be liable for an income tax for the cash withdrawal as well as in the event that the withdrawal amount is more than $10,000, you will be subject to a 10% penalty is due as well.7

The Bottom Line

Arguments regarding 401(k) loans “rob” or “raid” retirement accounts often include two flaws They assume constant positive returns to the stock market in the 401(k) portfolio and fail to consider the costs of borrowing similar amounts via banks or other types of consumer loans (such as the accumulation of the balance of credit cards).

Don’t be afraid to explore a valuable liquidity option embedded within your 401(k) scheme. When you lend yourself appropriate amounts of money for the right short-term reasons they can be the most simple, efficient, and least expensive option for cash. Before you make any loan, you should always have a plan in your mind to repay the loan in a timely manner or sooner.

Mike Loo, vice president of wealth management at Trilogy Financial, puts it as follows “While your circumstances when taking an 401(k) loan may vary however, one way to prevent the negatives of getting one in the first place is to be proactive. If you can take the time to preplan your financial goals, establish goals for your financial future and set a goal to save some of your money both frequently and in the early hours, you may find that you have money in an account other than your 401(k) which will eliminate the need for an 401(k) loan.”